Alternative Dispute Resolution

 

 

 

 

Arbitration in South Africa is designed to be a binding and enforceable process.

1. The Arbitration Award
Once the arbitrator has heard both sides and considered the evidence, they will issue a written, final, and binding arbitration award. This award is similar to a court judgment in that it resolves the dispute between the parties.

2. Enforcing the Award
Generally Binding: In most cases, the parties will comply with the arbitration award voluntarily. This is because the arbitration agreement they signed usually states that the award will be final and binding.

  • Making the Award an Order of Court: If one party refuses to comply, the other party can apply to the High Court to have the arbitration award made an order of court. Once the court makes the award an order, it has the same force and effect as a court judgment, and can be enforced in the same way. This may involve:
    • Execution: The winning party can use court processes to seize and sell the losing party's assets to satisfy the award.
    • Contempt of Court: If the losing party still refuses to comply, they can be held in contempt of court, which can lead to fines or even imprisonment.

3. Challenging the Award
Limited Grounds - The grounds for challenging an arbitration award are very limited. This is intentional, as it promotes the finality of arbitration and prevents parties from using delaying tactics.

  • Grounds for Challenge: The main grounds for challenging an award include:
    • Procedural irregularities: If the arbitration process was not conducted fairly or in accordance with the arbitration agreement.
    • Bias: If there is evidence of bias on the part of the arbitrator.
    • Public policy: If the award is contrary to the public policy of South Africa.
  • Court Review: A party can apply to the High Court to have the award set aside on these limited grounds. However, the court will generally be reluctant to interfere with the award unless there is a clear case of impropriety or illegality.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           
    In summary, arbitration awards in South Africa are generally binding and enforceable. The legal framework provides mechanisms to ensure compliance, and courts will only interfere in limited circumstances to uphold the integrity of the arbitration process.                   

 

  • Be Organized: Present your case in a clear and organized manner, with supporting evidence for your claims.
  • Be Concise: Avoid unnecessary repetition or lengthy arguments. Get straight to the point.
  • Be Professional: Maintain a professional attitude and demeanor throughout the proceedings.
  • Listen Carefully: Pay close attention to the arbitrator's questions and instructions, as well as the other party's arguments.
  • Seek Legal Advice: It is always advisable to seek legal advice from an experienced attorney who can guide you through the arbitration process.

By adhering to these guidelines, you can ensure that you present your case effectively and maintain a positive and productive atmosphere during the arbitration proceedings.

 

  • Disrespectful Behavior: Avoid interrupting the arbitrator, opposing counsel, or witnesses. Maintain a respectful demeanor throughout the proceedings.
  • Misrepresenting Facts: Honesty and transparency are crucial. Do not exaggerate, fabricate, or withhold information.
  • Unpreparedness: Ensure you are well-prepared with your evidence, documents, and arguments. Lack of preparation can weaken your case.
  • Ignoring Deadlines: Adhere to deadlines set by the arbitrator for submissions and other procedural matters.
  • Attempting to Influence the Arbitrator Improperly: Do not engage in ex-parte communication with the arbitrator outside of the formal proceedings.
  • Disruptive Conduct: Refrain from any behavior that could disrupt the proceedings, such as shouting, arguing excessively, or making personal attacks.

 

Irrelevant Information: Focus on presenting information that is directly relevant to the dispute at hand. Avoid rambling or introducing unrelated issues.
Emotional Outbursts: While arbitration can be emotionally charged, it's important to remain composed and avoid emotional outbursts or personal attacks.
Hearsay or Speculation: Stick to presenting factual evidence and avoid relying on hearsay or speculation.
Admitting Fault Unnecessarily: Be cautious about admitting fault or liability unless it is absolutely necessary.
Making False Accusations: Do not make false accusations against the other party or their representatives.
Threatening or Intimidating: Avoid any language or behavior that could be perceived as threatening or intimidating.

 

Show all FAQs in Category

 

 

Arbitration in South Africa - A Practical Guide for Businesses

Arbitration is a prominent method of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in South Africa, offering businesses a private, efficient, and often more cost-effective means of resolving disputes compared to traditional litigation. This guide provides a concise overview of arbitration in the South African context.

What is Arbitration?

Arbitration involves submitting a dispute to a neutral third party (an arbitrator) who, after hearing both sides, renders a legally binding decision (an arbitration award). This process is generally more flexible and less formal than court proceedings.

The Arbitration Foundation of Southern Africa (AFSA)

AFSA is a leading private dispute resolution institution in Southern Africa. It facilitates and administers various ADR mechanisms, including mediation, adjudication, and arbitration, for both domestic and international disputes. As a non-profit organization with a national presence, AFSA boasts a distinguished panel of experienced arbitrators and adjudicators. Notably, the King III Report on Corporate Governance recognizes AFSA as a preferred dispute resolution authority.

Advantages of Arbitration

Choice of Arbitrator - Parties can select an arbitrator with expertise in the specific area of the dispute.
Potential Cost Savings - Arbitration can significantly reduce legal costs compared to lengthy court battles.
Speed - Arbitration proceedings are generally faster than litigation, allowing businesses to minimize disruption.
Flexibility and Informality - The process is less formal and can be tailored to the unique needs of each dispute.
Confidentiality - Arbitration proceedings are typically private and confidential, protecting sensitive business information.

Potential Disadvantages of Arbitration

Cost - While often more cost-effective than litigation, arbitration still involves costs for arbitrator fees and administrative expenses.
Time - While generally faster than litigation, unforeseen circumstances can sometimes prolong the arbitration process.
Limited Appeal Rights - Unlike court judgments, arbitration awards have limited avenues for appeal, emphasizing the importance of a well-presented case.

Arbitration in Labour Disputes

South African labour legislation, including the Labour Relations Act (LRA), Employment Equity Act (EEA), Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA), and Skills Development Act (SDA), outlines specific procedures for referring labour disputes to arbitration or the Labour Court.

  • Referral Timeframes -  Parties have 90 days from the date of failed conciliation to refer a dispute to arbitration. Late referrals may require court approval.
  • Con-Arb Hearings - In certain cases, conciliation and arbitration are conducted consecutively on the same day (con-arb). This is mandatory for specific types of disputes.

The Arbitration Hearing

The arbitration hearing provides a platform for each party to present their case, including:

  • Presenting evidence and documents.
  • Cross-examining witnesses.
  • Conducting site inspections (if necessary).
  • The arbitrator ensures a fair and impartial hearing while minimizing unnecessary formalities.

Representation at Arbitration

Parties can represent themselves or be represented by:

  • An employee, director, or member (if a close corporation).
  • A representative from a registered trade union or employers' organization.
  • Legal counsel (generally permitted, with some exceptions in specific labour disputes).

The Arbitration Award

The arbitrator issues a written, final, and binding arbitration award within a specified timeframe. This award can be challenged through a review process in the Labour Court under limited circumstances.

Pre-Arbitration Conferences

For complex disputes, pre-arbitration conferences may be conducted to:

  • Exchange documents.
  • Agree on the scope of evidence.
  • Identify key witnesses.
  • Define the relief sought.
  • Conclusion

Contact us for help

Arbitration offers businesses in South Africa a valuable tool for resolving disputes efficiently and effectively. Our experienced legal team specializes in all aspects of arbitration and can provide expert guidance and representation throughout the process. Contact Us today to discuss your specific needs and explore how arbitration can benefit your business.