Employment and Labour Law

 

 

Yes, because constructive dismissal is considered a form of unfair dismissal, an employee who is found to have been constructively dismissed is generally eligible to claim unemployment insurance benefits (UIF), provided they meet the other requirements for claiming UIF.   
 

While the employer's intention can be a factor, the focus is more on the impact of their conduct on the employee and whether it made continued employment intolerable for a reasonable person.

Yes, an employee must refer a constructive dismissal dispute to the CCMA within 30 days of the date of their resignation. Failure to do so within this timeframe may result in the claim being rejected, although an application for condonation (late referral) can be made under certain circumstances.   

Employers can defend against a constructive dismissal claim by demonstrating that:

  1. The working conditions were not intolerable.
  2. They took reasonable steps to address the employee's concerns.
  3. The employee did not utilize available internal grievance procedures.   
  4. The employee's resignation was due to reasons other than the alleged intolerable conditions.

The burden of proof rests with the employee to prove that constructive dismissal occurred. They need to provide sufficient evidence to convince the CCMA or Labour Court that the working conditions were indeed intolerable due to the employer's conduct and that their resignation was a direct result thereof.   

Show all FAQs in Category

 

 

Constructive Dismissal  - A Guide for Employers and Employees

Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer, through their actions or omissions, makes the working environment so intolerable for the employee that the employee has no reasonable option but to resign. This is considered a form of dismissal by the law, even though the employee initiated the termination of the employment contract.

Key Elements of Constructive Dismissal

To successfully claim constructive dismissal, an employee must prove the following

1. Intolerable Working Conditions The employer's conduct must have created an intolerable working environment. This goes beyond mere unpleasantness or dissatisfaction; it requires a significant and substantial breach of the employment contract that makes continued employment unbearable. Examples can include:

  • Severe and persistent harassment: Sexual harassment, racial discrimination, bullying, and intimidation.
  • Unreasonable and unjustified disciplinary action: Unfair or baseless accusations, excessively harsh penalties.
  • Significant changes to employment conditions: Unilateral changes to salary, benefits, or working hours without proper consultation or agreement.
  • Demotion without justification:A significant demotion that is not based on legitimate business reasons.
  • Lack of support for employees with disabilities or health conditions.

2. Employer's Responsibility: The employer must be responsible for creating the intolerable working conditions. This requires demonstrating that the employer's actions or omissions directly contributed to the intolerable environment.

3. No Reasonable Alternatives The employee must demonstrate that they explored all reasonable alternatives to resignation, such as raising grievances, utilizing internal dispute resolution procedures, or seeking assistance from relevant authorities.

4. Causation The employee must prove that the employer's conduct directly caused the resignation. It must be shown that the resignation was a direct and foreseeable consequence of the employer's actions.

5. Objective Test The assessment of whether the working conditions were intolerable is based on an objective standard. The court will consider whether a reasonable person in the employee's position would have also felt compelled to resign due to the employer's conduct.

Employer Considerations

  • Maintain a Respectful Workplace  Employers have a legal and ethical obligation to maintain a respectful and supportive work environment.
  • Fair Treatment  Treat all employees fairly and consistently, regardless of their race, gender, religion, or other protected characteristics.
  • Effective Communication  Maintain open and effective communication channels with employees to address concerns and resolve disputes.
  • Follow Fair Procedures  Ensure that all disciplinary and performance management procedures are fair, consistent, and in accordance with relevant legislation.
  • Consult with Employees Consult with employees on significant changes to employment conditions, such as changes to working hours or remuneration.

Employee Considerations

  • Document Everything Keep detailed records of all incidents, including dates, times, witnesses, and any supporting documentation (emails, memos, etc.).
  • Utilize Internal Grievance Procedures Exhaust all internal grievance procedures before considering resignation.
  • Seek Legal Advice Consult with an experienced employment law attorney to assess your situation and advise on the best course of action.

Expert Legal Assistance for Constructive Dismissal Matters at Aucamp Inc.

Understanding constructive dismissal is crucial for both employers and employees in South Africa. As this guide illustrates, establishing a claim of constructive dismissal hinges on demonstrating the existence of truly intolerable working conditions and a lack of reasonable alternatives. Whether you are an employer seeking to ensure a fair and legally sound workplace, or an employee facing an unbearable work environment, navigating these complex legal waters requires careful consideration and expert guidance.

At Aucamp Inc., we possess the expertise to assist both employers and employees in understanding their rights and obligations in matters of constructive dismissal. If you believe you are facing a situation of constructive dismissal, or if you are an employer seeking to prevent such claims, we encourage you to reach out for a confidential consultation.

Protect your interests and ensure you have a clear understanding of your legal standing. Contact Aucamp Inc. today to discuss your constructive dismissal concerns.